Drywall that got wet from clean water and dried within 24 to 48 hours can often be saved. Drywall that stayed wet, got hit by dirty water, or is soft, sagging, or smells musty gets cut out and replaced.
Two things decide it: how long the board stayed wet and where the water came from. The best case is clean water from a supply line or a rain leak that gets dried quickly. If the board stayed solid, it can sometimes stay in place. Drywall that stays soaked for a couple of days gets weak, crumbles around the screws, and gives mold a place to grow. At that point we replace it, even if the surface looks fine. Water from a sewer backup or another dirty source means replacement no matter how fast it dried, because you can't clean the inside of a wet drywall panel. If the board is soft to the touch, bowing, stained all the way through, or the paper face is peeling, it has to go.
When we look at the damage, we'll tell you which sections can be dried and kept and which have to come out. We'd rather cut out one extra foot of board than paint over a problem you'll find again next winter.

